Robin Givhan

FASHION CRITIC AND STYLE WRITER

This site  The Web 

webassets/givhan14.jpg

OFF THE RUNWAY

Archive Newer | Older

Tuesday, September 21, 2010

Gabourey

I'm staring at the cover of Elle's issue featuring Gabourey Sidibe. And I'm wishing that I had the entire issue in my hand - rather than just a cover image - because I'd like to see how she's styled on the inside pages. I have a lot of faith in Joe Zee and Roberta Meyers because I think they are both smart and sensitive and I don't think they would intentionally do wrong by Gabourey.

 But I do not think the cover is attractive. I don't believe they lightened her complexion for any sort of nefarious reasons and I don't believe that anyone over at the magazine said, "Hey, let's do something really unflattering to her hair." Do I think they lit her like crazy in order to bring out more detail in her fact? Yes. Do I think that someone went bananas with the flash? Yes. Gabourey is a dark-skinned woman and it takes skill and practice in shooting someone with her skin tone so that they look like themselves and yet, the reader can see the nuances in her face. It's not brain surgery, but it doesn't just magically happen. And some might argue that any professional photographer worth his paycheck ought to be able to do it, I know more than a few well-paid hairstylists who'd have a coronary if they had to style nappy hair. 

Education is a powerful thing. I recall when Forrest Whittaker directed "Waiting to Exhale" and people commented on how beautiful all the black actresses looked. He responded that they had finally been lit properly. The lights had been set for them, not for a fairer skinned colleague with whom they were sharing a scene. 

Still, I think something went wrong with that cover. Gabourey is not a classic beauty. She has a lot of personality but she is also severely overweight and that makes finding clothes that will both fit and flatter her figure - clothes that are also age-appropriate - a challenge. If you're going to be in the beauty/fashion business, you should be able to take on any body type, etc. and show it off to its best potential. But it takes practice. And the problem here, is evidence that those folks involved didn't seem to have a whole lot of practice in working with her figure, her hair and her skin tone.

I recall when the model Alek Wek appeared on your cover. It was your cover, wasn't it? She looked stunning. But then, she's a model who knows how to show her face to its best potential.  

Gabourey looked better when she was featured in Ebony magazine. Ebony has more practice than Elle. So let this be a lesson to Elle, you need to do better. This, quite simply, was not an acceptable effort. You meant well and you misfired. 

That said, I also put a bit of responsibility at the feet of Gabourey herself and the folks who "handle" her. Someone should have taken a look in the mirror at the styling of her hair and said: This isn't working for me. As she becomes ever more famous, she has to be in charge of her own image. 

10:30 pm edt          Comments

Monday, September 6, 2010

Better Late Than Never...Maybe

So the whole Essence brouhaha erupted while I was on vacation and I was determined to enjoy my time away and not weigh in. Besides, I had planned to do a feature about the magazine's 40th anniversary. I'd had the conversation with the magazine's pr department. They were willing. I was tentatively scheduled to interview Angela Burt-Murray, the editor, when I returned from vacation. The point of the story was going to be how the mission of the magazine had changed over the years and how it might now be described when black women had accomplished so much. (See: FLOTUS)

I was hopeful that the magazine would go ahead and do the interview because I like to think that I always try to be fair and thoughtful. Alas. No interview. Of course, I went ahead with a column. But I do think it's unfortunate that the magazine didn't get out there and talk about the issue. As we're so fond of saying these days: It was a teachable moment.

Anyhoo, I thought it was worth noting that little bit of background on the column...which is linked to below.  

1:52 pm edt          Comments

Back to School

Okay. I admit that summer rolled around and I was remiss in posting. At first, I was just overcome by the heat of the sweltering Washington summer. But then I took some time off. I bought a new bicycle. I was enamored with the idea of commuting to the gym on it. I travelled to Detroit to see family. I went to a presentation of the Moth story telling hour which was hosted by WDET in Detroit. With not much encouragement from friends, something insane overtook me and I signed up to tell a story. That is NOT like me. But lo and behold, there I was on stage, telling a story about the first time I went to the White House for a first lady meeting and how it was 5,000 degrees outside and my single goal was to arrive for the meeting NOT looking like a sweat-drenched rat. I wasn't all that successful.

But now it's September and it's back to school time. Or for me, it's back to the fashion shows. Back to first lady coverage. (She was on vacation for much of August. Must be nice!)

I'm a little stressed about the start of fashion weeks around the world. New York kicks off with Fashion's Night Out, which has transformed into a giant city extravaganza. DC is doing its part with a night out in Georgetown. So much to see and do.

Then it's off to Europe where the Post would like me to discover some mind-bogglingly compelling story that makes the argument that the trip is worth the money. Why oh why does the euro/dollar exchange rate suck? I suspect the only thing that will truly make the trip financially sound is if both the Redskins and the mid-term elections suddenly start to figure prominently on the Paris runway. Maybe, if I'm lucky, designers will have some Washington-centric inspiration. In the meantime, nose to the grindstone.

Tomorrow afternoon, I will be at the White House for the launch of the first lady's dance series. The kick-off features a tribute to Judith Jamison of the Alvin Ailey Dance Theater. I'm not a dance expert, but that woman has more grace in a single arm gesture than anyone I've ever met.

By the way, I have a story in the September issue of British Elle. It's all about the current fashion season and whether designers have changed their ways when it comes to diversity. I am, as always, an optimist! Smile 

1:36 pm edt          Comments


Archive Newer | Older

UPCOMING EVENTS

Join me on May 11 in Washington, DC at "Suited for Spring" - a charity luncheon benefitting women re-entering the workforce

Podcast: "The Washington Catwalk: The Vivian R. Shaw lecture at the University of Michigan (Oct. 28, 2010)"

Robin Givhan

Create Your Badge


Biography

 

Robin Givhan grew up in Detroit, Michigan. She received her Bachelor of Arts in English from Princeton University and a Masters of Science in journalism from the University of Michigan.

 

In 1988, she began her career in journalism at the Detroit Free Press, where she was a general assignment entertainment writer. As the newest member of a section dominated by experienced critics, she was left to carve out her own niche: nightlife. She documented the rise of the techno music industry in Detroit.

 

She left Detroit for a brief stint as a feature writer at the San Francisco Chronicle, where among other topics she wrote about a local radio talk show host who successfully counseled teenagers in crisis over the airwaves.

 

She returned to Detroit as fashion editor in the early 1990s and moved to the Washington Post in 1995.

 

Since that time, she has been the fashion editor of the Washington Post where she covers the news, trends and business of the international fashion industry. Her work is distinguished by the way in which it examines fashion through the lens of popular culture, politics and social anthropology.

 

In 2009, she began covering Michelle Obama and the cultural and social shifts stirred by the first African American family in the White House.

 

She lives and works in Washington, DC. 

 

Her work has also appeared in Harper’s Bazaar, American Vogue, British Vogue, Marie Claire, Essence and the New Yorker. She has contributed to several books including “Runway Madness,” “No Sweat: Fashion, Free Trade and the Rights of Garment Workers” and “Thirty Ways of Looking at Hillary: Reflections by Women Writers.”

 

She has received numerous awards including several from the American Association of Sunday and Feature Editors. In 2007, she received the Eugenia Sheppard award for journlism from the Council of Fashion Designers of America. In 2006, she won the Pulitzer Prize in criticism for her fashion coverage.

 


In 2010, her book "Michelle: Her First Year As First Lady" was published in conjunction with the Washington Post.

webassets/pulitzer3.jpg

RECENT STORIES

Why Fashion Keeps Tripping Over Race

The American fashion industry has a hissy fit over the first lady's state dinner gown

FLOTUS wears McQueen at the State Dinner for China

New York Fall 2011: a big so-what.

London Fashion is Ready for the Spotlight

Paris Fashion in the Aftermath of Dior

Fashion's Mean Girls

Middleton Madness

The Dior Debaucle

Armani Goes Gaga

Fashion's New "It" Girl

I (heart) Constance!

Dowdy By Choice

Crime Victim Photos

The Supreme Black Robe

Fashion and the Burqa

The New Fashion Guard

Tom Ford Returns

The Essence Kerfuffle

FLOTUS and her vacation wardrobe

Stacy London and Style for Hire

The Meaning of Hillary's New Hairdo

Naomi vs. Charles Taylor

Enough About Chelsea's Wedding!

FLOTUS and the Arts: An Interview

Fatshionista Rebellion

The Fabulousness of Serena Williams

Wonder Woman!

Lady Gaga is not a Fashion Icon

100 Years of Zegna

Style Bullies

CFDA Awards

The Meaning of Jeans

FLOTUS in my hometown

Black Fashion Museum

Elena Kagan: The Column That Roiled the Blogosphere

History in a Closet

Not the Usual Bold Face Suspects

Waiting Tables at a State Dinner

The Mexico City Trip

What do First Ladies do when they go abroad?

A pitstop in Haiti

Michelle Obama in Mexico pt. 1

Michelle Obama in Mexico City pt. 2

Obesity Task Force Report

Costume Institute Exhibition: American Woman

The great Dorothy Height

Happy Easter

No Fashion Smackdowns

CFDA Awards

Fall 2010 Fashion Show Coverage

Alexander McQueen's Final Collection

Timing is Everything

Runways Online

Balenciaga et al.

Milan tussles with power dressing

Young designers hanging on!

Being a grown-up isn't easy

Defining American beauty

Bye-bye Bryant Park

Desiree Rogers: Victim of Fashion?

Alexander McQueen Dies

Katie Couric: Power Anchor

Figure Skating Madness

First Lady Announces: Let's Move

White House Welcomes a Young Man

FLOTUS and military families

The Weight Debate

Michelle Obama Interview

Eunice Johnson tribute

Michelle Obama's first year

The Obamas as pitchpeople

Sexism in the Tiger Woods scandal

Blonde Privilege

Desiree Rogers

Obama's first state dinner

Will commoners sit at the State Dinner?

State Dinner Fashion

John Allen Mohammad execution

Madeleine Albright's pins

PULITZER-PRIZE PORTFOLIO

In 2006, I became the first fashion writer to win a Pulitzer Prize for criticism.

These are the stories that were submitted to the judges.

Where to find me: 
Newsweek Daily Beast
1750 Pennsylvania Ave. NW
Suite 1220
Washington, DC 20006
202-626-2018

CONTACT ME

Powered by Register.com